The borough of Rattleborough was a sleepy, contented little American town until the summer when Mr. Barnabas Shuttleworthy disappeared. He was the wealthiest man in the place and one of the most respected, a hearty old gentleman who liked his dinner, his wine and his friends, and who swore a good deal in a harmless way. One Saturday morning he set out on horseback for the city, some fifteen miles away, saying that he would be back that night. Two hours later his horse came home alone, without its rider and without the saddlebags that had been strapped across it. The poor animal was covered with blood from a pistol shot that had gone clean through its chest without quite killing it.
The whole town was thrown into alarm. And no one seemed more stricken than Mr. Charles Goodfellow, whom everyone called Old Charley.